Trackback This Post | Subscribe to the comments through RSS Feed
Conservative columnist Robert Novak said he did not hear forceful objection from the husband of a then-undercover CIA agent before her name was printed in his infamous column that sparked a years-long legal battle over his sources.
“He was not terribly exercised about it,” Novak said, referring to Ambassador Joseph Wilson, whose wife Valerie Plame Wilson was outed in his July 2003 column. Novak’s comments to the Society of Professional Journalists convention were reported Monday in The Hill.
Wilson refuted that charge in an interview with RAW STORY Monday.
“I hope he’s going to confession, because if not he’s surely going to Hell for his lies,” Wilson said.
Wilson, who had just published a column undercutting the Bush administrations claims about Iraq’s weapons capabilities, asked Novak before the column appeared not to portray him simply as a war critic, the Hill reported. And Novak told the crowd that Wilson stressed that his wife went by his last name, rather than her maiden name (Novak’s column reported her name as Valerie Plame).
“The question of my wife’s last name never came up,” Wilson said.
Rather, he says he asked Novak to stop telling people around Washington that his wife worked for the CIA.
“It is a compromise of my family’s personal responsibility and safety … not to mention treasonous,” said Wilson, who did not confirm to Novak that Valerie Wilson was a CIA agent.
Novak slammed his critics for attacking his ethics, saying they really had a problem with his ideology. He said his case demonstrates the need for a federal shield law to protect journalists.
“I was stunned by how little editorial support I received. I was under assault from editorial writers from across the country,” Novak said. “It is startling how little is known about this case by the people who are commenting on it.”
The Senate Judiciary Committee last week approved a reporters’ shield law, that would protect journalists from having to disclose the identities of confidential sources or hand over to authorities any records, documents or notes from confidential sources. The Washington Post reports that the new law would have a broad definition of who was covered that would include, reporters, columnists and bloggers but could exclude employees of news organizations owned by foreign governments, such as al-Jazeera or the BBC.
Novak defended his reporting Valerie Wilson’s name, and said the disclosure was not part of a Bush administration effort to smear a prominent war critic. He also said it is “hypocritical” for his critics to support a shield law “that would have saved me from three years of confrontation.”
To Wilson, Novak’s “I’m a victim” defense is little more than a last resort aimed more at upping his book sales than setting the record straight.
“He’s trying to flog his book,” Wilson charged, “on my back and my wife’s back.”
Popularity: 1% [?]
Wilson is right. I had a friend who was outted and he was killed in a drive by. A humanist killed by someone’s ego. Guys like Novak get a warm place in hell. Information can be a bio-hazard and responsible reporters know that.
Wilson’s old lady was never a deep cover agent. She’s not a “Ranch” grad. By the time her name popped up she had been at Langley for nearly six years.
Their neighbors and social circle knew she worked for the agency. She and Joe were never in any danger other living in the DC area.
Mr. Harrington,
can you categorically say without a single iota of doubt that Valerie Plame Wilson did not face danger fater being outed? Or any of her colleagues? I think that if it were your wife or your daughter that your inability to assess danger would change dramatically.
The point is, I wouldn’t want the name of a janitor who worked at the CIA to be leaked to the press…and I’m certain that you and Mr. Novak understand the full implications of the leak but prefer to sound tough and unfazed by the danger the woman was placed in.
It would be so refreshing to see Americans pretend that we were all on the same team again rather than being ripped about apart petty party alliances. How sad we have become, a nation that was founded on truth and freedom. No wonder that we have become an international joke!
By Danny Schechter
As millions of homes are foreclosed upon, as unemployment grows and inflation mounts, it is time to understand the origins of the crisis and the need to fight for economic justice.
Written by veteran media critic and Emmy winner Rory O'Connor, Shock Jocks features unsparing profiles of the ten worst conservative radio talkers in America, including Michael Savage, Bill O' Reilly, Rush Limbaugh, Don Imus and the rest.